Rhythm Exchange Records

---

Are you buying records because you genuinely love them, or because they’ll look good on Instagram?

If you’ve ever caught yourself angling a record at the perfect light, worrying whether your turntable looks “aesthetic” enough, or buying an album purely for the cover art and potential likes, you’re not alone. I spent six months trying to turn my vinyl hobby into Instagram content, and it nearly destroyed the thing I loved most about collecting.

Here’s the uncomfortable truth about performative vinyl collecting that nobody talks about, and how I found my way back to actually enjoying music again.

The Instagram Vinyl Aesthetic Trap

It started innocently enough. I was scrolling through Instagram one evening, the kind of mindless doom-scrolling we all do after a long day. That’s when the algorithm served up the reel, you know the type.

Slick, stylised imagery. Long, sweeping pans past lush retro HiFi equipment perfectly arranged on lovingly restored mid-century modern furniture. Artistically draped exotic plants. The whole setup bathed in that perfect golden-hour lighting that makes everything look like a Wes Anderson film.

The guy in the clip casually pulled out a Blue Note label copy of Art Blakey and the Messengers’ Moanin’. His movements were impossibly smooth, like watching a professional card dealer at a high-stakes poker game. He ran an expensive looking anti-static brush over the record, followed by some cleaning solution and a felt pad. It was methodical, almost ritualistic, with serious ASMR appeal.

When the needle finally dropped, the camera panned across the album cover, then back to the pristine vintage setup. The whole thing screamed “chilled vibes” and made me feel 30% cooler just by watching.

I was hooked. And I knew I’d been influenced by someone who had absolutely nailed my particular niche.

But what I didn’t realize then was that I was becoming one of several distinct types of vinyl collectors, each with their own motivations and blind spots, and mine was all about the performance.

The Numbers Game

I looked at his account. 300,000+ followers. His feed was full of nearly identical clips, different albums, same aesthetic perfection. Meanwhile, my modest record collection account was struggling to maintain 400 followers after weeks of consistent posting.

I felt jealous, anxious, and honestly a bit depressed. This was the moment I had to decide: keep grinding away at Instagram, or give it up altogether.

When Vinyl Collecting Becomes Content Creation

Before that algorithm-induced existential crisis, I’d been slowly building my account to connect with like-minded vinyl collectors. I genuinely wanted to monetize my hobby, turn it into passive income for buying more records. The “influencer lifestyle” dream, right?

Social media platforms play a massive role in vinyl culture, with over 252 million vinyl-related posts on TikTok and 39 million on Instagram. These platforms have transformed collecting into a shared social experience, blending analog music with digital expression.

My early posts were simple: faceless shots of records, witty captions, well-known tracks. Nothing fancy. And the metrics showed it, I was getting a few likes, maybe some follows, but nothing substantial.

The Content Treadmill

I knew what the problem was, and it was frustrating as hell. Social media is designed as a dopamine hit for viewers. Content needs to be punchy, quick, attention-grabbing. It’s like trying to hold the attention of a tank full of goldfish.

So I dove into the rabbit hole: YouTube videos about social media marketing, hundreds of blogs, online marketing courses promising “100k followers guaranteed with our foolproof system” for just $49.99.

The line between hobby and side hustle has blurred, with every creative act now coming with the question: “Could I sell this?” or “Is this good content?” What should have been intimate acts of joy became performances aimed at likes, followers, and potential customers.

I watched my follower count hover around 400 for weeks, fluctuating like a failed cryptocurrency portfolio. Gain followers, lose followers. Rinse and repeat.

I was stuck. Disillusioned. Exhausted.

The Pressure to Perform

Here’s the harsh reality: to succeed on social media, you need to be the perfect embodiment of exactly the type of person others wish they were.

It’s not real. It’s not genuine. And it takes enormous amounts of work to look effortless.

I started considering purchases I couldn’t afford: those highly coveted limited-release albums on the wall at my local record store, various “accoutrements” for my listening area, VU meters, lava lamps, funky slipmats, maybe an Ortofon cartridge upgrade.

But for what? Insta-cred?

I was buying records not because I wanted to hear them, but because of how they’d look on my feed. If you’ve ever caught yourself doing the same, you’re not alone, and you’re probably one of four distinct collector types that dominate the modern vinyl world.

The Wake-Up Call

The breaking point came when I walked into a record store and seriously considered dropping a small fortune on an original British first pressing of London Calling by The Clash. The only thing that stopped me was imagining my wife’s face when I told her we’d be missing this month’s mortgage payment, but hey, want to listen to “Guns of Brixton” again?

This was insane.

I wasn’t collecting for myself anymore. I was collecting for strangers on the internet. For validation. For that next dopamine hit of likes and comments.

When hobbies become performative, mistakes aren’t lessons, they’re failures, and the joy gets replaced by deadlines, expectations, and burnout.

What Vinyl Collecting Is Actually About

It was supposed to be about the music.

About the joy of dropping a needle on a record you love and hearing those warm analog tones fill your living room. About rediscovering albums you’d forgotten while flipping through crates at local record stores. About the thrill of finding that one record you’ve been hunting for years at a price you can actually afford.

It’s not meant to be about:

• Staging the perfect shot
• Agonizing over whether your turntable looks retro enough
• Worrying if your collection is “curated” enough for the algorithm
• Buying records because they’ll make good content instead of because you love them

About 50% of Gen Z vinyl collectors say the hobby offers a break from digital life, while 61% report using vinyl listening to replace digital habits and improve mental well-being.

How I Reclaimed the Joy of Vinyl Collecting

So here I am, a failed and slightly jaded content creator, coming clean about what really matters.

I stopped posting on Instagram. I stopped worrying about whether my setup looked “aesthetic enough.” I stopped buying records based on how they’d photograph.

And something amazing happened: I started enjoying music again.

5 Signs Your Vinyl Collecting Has Become Performative

If you’re reading this and feeling that uncomfortable pang of recognition, here are the warning signs:

1. You’re buying records for the ‘gram, not your ears If your first thought when you see a record is “this would get good engagement” rather than “I can’t wait to hear this,” you’ve crossed the line.

2. You’ve started curating your collection for others Hiding albums you genuinely love because they’re not “cool enough” or prominently displaying records you’ve never even played.

3. The ritual feels like work When putting on a record becomes about lighting, angles, and hashtags instead of about the experience of listening.

4. You feel anxious about your setup Constantly comparing your equipment to what you see online, feeling inadequate because your turntable isn’t vintage enough or your speakers aren’t photogenic.

5. You’ve forgotten why you started Can’t remember the last time you put on a record without documenting it. The joy has been replaced by obligation.

Finding Balance in the Age of Social Media

Around half of all global social media users want to spend more time on alternative, community-driven platforms that emphasize authenticity over performance.

I’m not suggesting you completely abandon social media if you’re a vinyl collector. Instagram can be an unparalleled platform for music discovery and connecting with other collectors through the human touch of photography and personal recommendations.

But there’s a difference between sharing your passion and performing it.

How to Stay Authentic

Set boundaries: Maybe you post once a week instead of daily. Maybe you only share records you’re genuinely excited about, not just ones that look good.

Join authentic communities: Look for forums, Discord servers, or local record collecting groups where the focus is on music, not aesthetics.

Remember it’s okay to keep things private: Not every listening session needs to be documented. Some of the best moments are just for you.

Focus on the music first: If you find yourself thinking about the photo before you’ve even heard the album, pause and reassess.

The Gen X Perspective

Here’s the thing: I’m in my 50s. I’m kind of late to this game.

In reality, I’m just a guy who likes to listen to records on the weekend while having a cheeky beer or two. The young guys with perfectly curated feeds and effortless cool? That’s so far removed from me it’s laughable.

Trying to relate to a younger audience on the internet feels like being the weird uncle at his nephew’s 21st birthday, wearing an old band t-shirt unironically, trying to tell boring anecdotes about that time you saw some random bass player from a band nobody’s heard of at a bar that doesn’t exist anymore.

And you know what? That’s completely fine.

I’m too old school to be “cool,” and that might just be the most liberating realisation of all.

The Irony Isn’t Lost on Me

Yes, I’m writing a blog post about how content creation nearly killed my vinyl hobby. That’s another piece of content about content.

But here’s why it’s different: this format keeps me more real and less likely to agonize over aesthetics. It’s about sharing genuine thoughts and experiences, not performing a carefully curated lifestyle.

In 2025, many users feel overwhelmed by societal pressures amplified by social platforms, such as comparison, online drama, and constant performance of identity, leading to a broader cultural shift toward intentional tech use and authenticity.

Your Vinyl Journey Should Be Yours

If you’re reading this and you collect vinyl, ask yourself these questions:

• Are you buying records because you want to hear them, or because others might think they’re cool?
• Is the joy of collecting being replaced by the anxiety of content creation?
• Have you forgotten why you fell in love with vinyl in the first place?

If the answer makes you uncomfortable, maybe it’s time to step back.

For me, vinyl was never about follower counts or perfectly lit videos. It was about the music, the ritual, the tangible connection to art. When I first started collecting, there was no social media, no internet. Just music lovers sharing their passion in record stores and with friends.

Maybe that’s what we need to get back to.

Resources for Authentic Vinyl Collectors

Instead of chasing the Instagram aesthetic, here are some genuinely valuable resources:

• Local record stores: Build relationships with staff who can help you discover new music based on what you actually enjoy
• Discogs: For tracking your collection and finding specific pressings you’re hunting for
• Record Store Day: Support independent stores and discover limited releases
• Reddit communities like r/vinyl: Where conversations focus on the music and gear, not just pretty photos (although I have noticed a bit of validation hunting creeping in a bit on this sub of late)
• Vinyl-focused forums: Where knowledge-sharing trumps performing

Final Thoughts: Reclaiming Joy

I’m not anti-social media. I’m not saying everyone should quit Instagram or stop sharing their collections.

What I am saying is this: don’t let the pursuit of online validation steal the joy from the thing you love.

Your hobby deserves better than to be reduced to content. You deserve better than the constant anxiety of performance. And your records? They deserve to be played, enjoyed, and loved, camera on or off.

After all, the best sound in the world is a needle dropping on a record you’re genuinely excited to hear, in a room where nobody’s watching, where it doesn’t matter if the lighting is perfect or if your turntable is Instagram-worthy.

That’s where the real magic happens.

---

Do you collect vinyl? Have you felt the pressure to make your hobby “content-worthy”? How do you stay authentic in the age of social media? I’d genuinely love to hear your thoughts in the comments below. Let’s reclaim the joy of collecting together.

---

Continue Reading:

• Why Do People Collect Vinyl in 2026? 4 Collector Types Explained – Discover whether you’re an investment flipper, variant completist, reissue-only buyer, or checklist collector (and why it matters)
• How to Build an Affordable HiFi Setup That Actually Sounds Good – If you’re going to collect vinyl, at least play it on equipment that does it justice

---